Completed this today. Might go back to finish up the last few trophies for the platinum, but not super invested in doing so.
Good:
Pretty good characters overall. Cal is boring but gets better. I particularly liked Nightsister Merrin and Trilla.
While they don't go too deep, they do have several scenes where good and bad guys debate their respective views, which typically only the best Star Wars properties do.
The 3D Map is solid, clearly labeling where you can't go because you're missing an ability, or where you now can but couldn't before.
Level design itself is ok.
Completion goals are labeled by map section to make it easy to find everything.
Exploring certain lore-important planets was cool, although most of them have appeared in other properties.
Bad:
Crashed multiple times on PS4.
Frame Rate often dropped low enough to be unplayable, especially as an action RPG where parrying is required.
Fell through the map several times.
Levels are so heavily designed "as video game levels" that all immersion is completely broken. There were like 50+ places where Stormtroopers show up that they literally couldn't get to without being Jedi to swing on vines, run across walls, flip in mid-air, or climb on normally-unclimbable vegetation (which also happens to be growing exactly where you need it, even in tombs thousands of years old). I wouldn't be able to believe anyone lived or worked in these locations. (This isn't a deal-breaker of course. Nioh has the same problem, trying to mesh real life historical figures and locations with super video-gamey levels.)
Lots of enemies and bosses like to spam unblockable moves, many of which have no right being unblockable by their animations.
Command buffers are even more egregious than in Souls games, as it'll remember 2-4 moves you input and do them all in order several seconds after you pressed them, instead of correcting to your current inputs.
Had to reload 3-4 times where triggers didn't happen to open doors (or BD-1 to unlock them).
Upgrade system is pretty meh, nothing all that exciting. Collectibles are mainly skins.
Overall it's just ok. Cutscenes were good and interesting, some of the puzzles were decent, but it didn't feel all that fun to "play".
